The Ultimate Guide to Custom-Fit Dress Shirts: Why Fit Matters

Whether you’re tired of shirts that don’t fit right or just looking to up your appearance, the obvious starting point is graduating from off-the-rack options to custom-fit dress shirts.

The Problem with Off-the-Rack Shirts

Sure, off-the-rack fits some gents. But for the rest of us, small, medium, and large options don’t cut it. Adding in a sleeve and neck sizing doesn’t offer much sizing range.

  • Poor Sizing Options: Standard sizes rarely consider torso and arm length or shoulder and chest width, forcing guys into choosing from standard sizes that don’t match their measurements.
  • Standardized Construction: Mass-produced shirts aim to create a size that will fit most, like a boxy, unflattering shape aimed at “the average guy” but doesn’t fit most. Additionally, off-the-rack often chases trends that may not reflect your taste, like trying to put everyone in a super slim-fit shirt.
  • Inconsistencies Across Brands: Small, medium, and large may vary widely across brands, creating an unpredictable sizing experience.

Why Fit Matters in Dress Shirts

  • Flattering Appearance: A dress shirt made to your measurements and your style preferences creates a clean, sharp silhouette that flatters.
  • All-Day Comfort: Rather than forcing your way into a shirt that’s too small or fighting the extra fabric of a shirt that’s too large, custom-fit dress shirts have the right amount of room and give, keeping you comfortable.
  • Confidence Boost: A made-to-measure shirt looks and feels better, giving you a little extra self-assurance in the morning.

Key Areas of Fit

  • Collar: Should fit snugly but allow room for two fingers.
  • Shoulders: Seams should sit at the edge of your shoulders.
  • Chest & Waist: Tailored, but not tight, to provide shape without restriction.
  • Sleeves: Cuffs should stop before your hands and be easy to button without being loose.
  • Length: Long enough to tuck in comfortably without easily slipping out throughout the day.

The Benefits of Custom-Fit Shirts

  • Perfect Fit for Every Body Type: Custom-fit dress shirts don’t require sacrifice. A shirt made to your unique measurements guarantees a flattering fit.
  • Premium Fabrics: Rather than accepting the colors, patterns, and materials a company offers, custom allows you to select high-quality materials based on texture, weight, style, patterns, and colors.
  • Personalization Options: A good shirtmaker allows you to select essential details.
  • Durability and Long-Term Value: Custom usually costs more upfront, but higher-quality materials are more durable, allowing the shirt to last longer.
  • Sustainability: Custom means made when there’s demand, avoiding unsold products. Better materials will last longer and not require a replacement as soon.

The Proper Cloth Process

  • Easy Online Sizing: Most customers start with Proper Cloth’s Smart Size Quiz, an algorithm based on thousands of data points. Other ways to create a size include measuring a shirt, mailing a shirt, measuring your body, or visiting a showroom.
  • Fabric Selection: Once you know your size, you can choose from a massive library of fabrics, ranging from material to weight to style.
  • Style Personalization: Put your stamp on your dress shirt by choosing the style of your cuffs, collar, hem, pockets, and more.
  • Saved Profiles: After you create a size, you can order new shirts in your existing size or create new profiles for different styles.
  • Fast Delivery: Proper Cloth usually has your new custom-fit shirts at your door in under two weeks.
  • Real Customer Services: We offer free remakes and free returns. We also have a variety of ways to get in touch with customer service, including speaking with a real person on the phone.

Design Your Custom Shirt Today

If you’re ready to elevate your wardrobe with custom-fit dress shirts, you can get started by creating a size. With a fit guarantee, free returns and remakes, a library of fabrics, and customization options, Proper Cloth is an easy, risk-free, and sophisticated way to take your style up a notch.

Want to hear the hype from someone else? Check out our recent write-up in The New York Times Wirecutter.