Recent Shirt Reviews
“I was amazed at the quality and how well the shirt fit!”
Thomas in Arlington, VA
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
16 hours ago
Excellent shirts and easy experience. I did enjoy the ability to customize everything about the shirt. Currently going through some fit testing and having the shirts evaluated via your feedback systems.
Ryan in Houston, TX
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
16 hours ago
Great
Nicholas in Jersey City, NJ
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
14 hours ago
Why would you ever order a shirt from anywhere else? The shirt always fits and their quality and style are unmatched.
Blaze in Dickinson, TX
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
18 hours ago
3
Nelson in Doral, FL
★★★★★
“Being able to customize the size of each part of the shirt is game-changing for a guy built like me (broad up top, narrow waist, sort of long arms). The Smart Size feature is pretty accurate, a great place to start… Overall good experience. I intend to order more.
Jeff in Lusk, Wyoming
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
18 hours ago
.
Nelson in Doral, FL
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
8 hours ago
High quality and easy to use
Tyler in Ruston, WA
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
4 hours ago
Proper Cloth provides the best service in menswear.
Marcelo in Nagoya, Aichi
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
11 hours ago
Positive, as always. Been getting my shirts here for years.
Jeffrey in Belmont, CA
Find out how easy it is to get perfect fitting shirts with Proper Cloth.
GET STARTED NOWRating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
9 hours ago
Excellent experience. Fabric was as described. Would wear for work and casual outings only. Not formal. Wrinkle description is accurate.
David in Pembroke Pines, FL
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
18 hours ago
Love the level of customization that can be applied and that the price is ‘all in’. Every order is getting closer and closer to being a perfect fit. My first order took a couple of adjustments to get pretty much correct; my second is basically perfect as is. I expect to only make very minor adjustments (fractions of inches) in future.
Andrew in Toronto, ON
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
1 hour ago
A very relaxed and high-quality shopping experience! The customer service is also professional and extremely courteous!
Frank in Hamburg, Hamburg
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
18 hours ago
I really like the quality of the fabrics as well as the amount of choices. I have always wanted to wear some shirts untucked, but have rarely been able to find them in a length that worked for me "off the shelf." Proper Cloth's custom fit has been the answer.
Nick in Jersey City, NJ
★★★★★
“Excellent from start to finish. I have a unique body type and was skeptical just by answering questions if I would get a proper fit. Long story short - the shirts fit great! The quality is excellent as well as the choices in fabric and style.
David in Cincinnati, OH
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
16 hours ago
Always a great experience
Patrick in New Albany, OH
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
19 hours ago
I do want a remake or at least a discussion on the Overshirt on my last order and I have not laundered it yet.whats the best way to communicate my issue?
John in Uniontown, PA
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
Yesterday
Class customer service !
Steven in Dix Hills, NY
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
8 hours ago
Easy to use website and consistency are a couple of the main reasons I keep coming back. I always know what I can expect.
Brian in Houston, TX
Find out how easy it is to get perfect fitting shirts with Proper Cloth.
GET STARTED NOWRating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
13 minutes ago
Proper Cloth has been my go-to shirt source for years. Their system is so well designed, user friendly and dependably consistent. I love their selection of materials and styles. The attention to detail is extraordinary. I just received two more shirts from Proper Cloth and they feel and look fantastic. I will remain a loyal customer!
Mark in Port Matilda, PA
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
21 hours ago
As always, Mia is absolutely fantastic. But, I'm still waiting for my shirts. Can someone help here?
Anthony in New York, NY
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
20 hours ago
It was good. Solid customer experience. Fabric is great and liked that I could have blue buttons.
Kenneth in Aurora, CO
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
20 hours ago
I love the merino cloths for shirting! I jumped at this colour. However, the usual high quality of the construction wasn't quite as fine and the sleeves are slightly longer than the ones I have previously ordered (despite not changing my measurements from previous orders). I will get my local tailor to fix it.
Shyam in London, London
★★★★★
“Excellent service, shipping and product. Husband's recent white dress shirt even stood up to a quick & easy clean up, about 1 hour after he put the shirt on & spilled something red on it just before we needed to head out the door. My husband & I can really see and feel the difference in wearing your tailored shirts, he even looks younger.
Deidre in Coldwater, MI
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
20 hours ago
Outstanding as usual.
Ben in Encinitas, CA
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
20 hours ago
Only after the third order did the shirt finally fit according to the measurements I had specified. While this took some patience, I truly appreciated the helpful and friendly customer service, which made the experience positive overall.
Lars in Berlin,
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
20 hours ago
Start with the no iron broadcloth.
Brooks in Fort Collins, CO
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
20 hours ago
I've been a customer since 2014 and came in for a refit in July 2025. Thank you to team at 681 Fifth Ave for their courteous and professional help. I just received my new order and am extremely happy with the shirts and the size adjustments. Thank you to Mia and Craig for their help and patience
Sal in Sherman, CT
Find out how easy it is to get perfect fitting shirts with Proper Cloth.
GET STARTED NOWRating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
13 hours ago
It is always seemless and awesome.
Michael in Saint Paul, MN
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
10 hours ago
Fantastic...love the custom shirts
John in Anna, OH
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
15 hours ago
Proper cloth always does a great job of getting my clothes fitting great and looking smart. I order all the time from them and am almost never disappointed by a product - which is about 98% better than ordering from a non-custom shop.
Patrick in Oakland, CA
Rating Breakdown
-
Website
-
Fabric
-
Construction
-
Fit
-
Customer Service
Yes, would order again
20 hours ago
Love my new seersucker shirt. I've always wanted one that fit me well and now I have it!
Clifford in Middle River, MD
★★★★★
“As a small man, I have difficulty buying shirts in retail stores that truly fit. These are the best fitting and most well-made shirts I’ve ever owned. Materials are first quality and very stylish. I would highly recommend Proper Cloth to anyone who wants top quality clothing that to TRULY wants a custom fit.
Peter in Naples, FL