CUSTOMER REVIEWS (REAL-TIME, UNFILTERED, HONEST)
Based on  2,905   reviews:
95%  of customers say they will order from Proper Cloth again.
Yes
No
DATE PURCHASED COMMENTS RATINGS
May 23,
2013
Best fitting shirt i have ever owned.
Would you order again? YES
Iowa City, IA
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
4/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 23,
2013
The online customization process is much smoother and easier than I would have expected. My first attempt at sizing was very close, and much better than any off-the-shelf shirt would fit. After that, you can just use any changes to fine tune.
Would you order again? YES
Baton Rouge, LA
5/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 23,
2013
Excellent service, easy to use website if you know your shirting desires or are new to the process of made to order.
Would you order again? YES
Yukon, OK
5/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
4/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
First shirt cannot be perfect even after first alteration but you may finally get the perfect fit from the second order.
Would you order again? YES
Pittsburgh, PA
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
Great experience. Prompt (and complimentary!) alteration solved the one fit problem (sleeve length) with my first shirt. I've already received my second and am planning to order one or two more each month.
Would you order again? YES
Clermont, FL
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
Very smooth process. Love the site. Perhaps add an athletic cut with more V-taper by default. Not sure why you keep the default mid-section so large, even if you enter a small waist measurement. I manually dropped the Midsection width way down (for 9" total drop) and it looks great! No more bunching up my shirt in the back.
Would you order again? YES
Dallas, TX
5/5
Website
3/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
Shirt is great. I think it would be a great improvement if you guys offered military style sheets as well: dual pockets epaulettes and seamed front and backs.
Would you order again? YES
Redondo Beach, CA
4/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
4/5
Service
May 22,
2013
Really positive experience. I would generally recommend getting measured by a tailor instead of doing it yourself. Also, more templates would be nice. Picking out every little detail is daunting, but choosing a general style and color and getting a perfect fit is far beyond what any off-the-rack retailer can offer.
Would you order again? YES
Redwood city, CA
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
These were my first custom shirts, and I measured myself at home to calculate the sizing. Everything fit perfectly the first time around, and the fabrics are gorgeous. The blue broadcloth is very light (great for summer), but it is a bit seethrough. The entry-level pinpoints are well constructed and not seethrough, but it's definitely worth springing for the non-iron fabrics. The plain fabrics do get a lot of creases by the end of the day, while the non-iron ones still look great. These are the best fitting shirts I've ever owned, and I would definitely recommend trying one out.
Would you order again? YES
Glen Ellyn, IL
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
Following multiple attempts to have shirts custom made, I've found Proper Cloth to be the most user-friendly, seamless option with great results. Have recommended the company to several friends, and intend to continue using it myself.
Would you order again? YES
New York, NY
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
As usual, you guys are right on top it! Thanks
Would you order again? YES
Birmingham, AL
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
Highly recommend viewing options with your shirts (fit/pattern/etc.) via human model.
Would you order again? YES
Phoenix, AZ
4/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
This is the first set of shirts I have ordered after we figured my size out. There really is no reason not to get all of your shirts from PC. Once you have the size dialed in, you are getting a perfectly tailored shirt at an unbeatable price. Excellent value.
Would you order again? YES
McAllen, TX
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
General experience was good. Measuring an existing shirt is one thing I wish I had done instead of just taking my own measurements, as it would've clued me in on some key changes to the recommended settings vs. measurements before the original order.
Would you order again? YES
Chicago, IL
3/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
4/5
Service
May 22,
2013
The shirt was a disaster and has already been returned and a new shirt ordered. The collar was wrong, no pocket, and I didn't request cuffs, yet somehow they all ended up on the final order form. I checked the form twice but not the last time when I got the 2 day warning. (I will from now on.) But Brittany took care of it and a new shirt is on its way, hopefully one that meets my wants.
Would you order again? YES
Woodcliff Lake, NJ
2/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
4/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
Experience was great. Very helpful...any questions/issues were answered quickly.
Would you order again? YES
Floral Park, NY
5/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
4/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 22,
2013
Proper Cloth was amazing!!!! My original shirt felt extremely loose. I brought it into Proper Cloth, they took a look at it, made some changes, and got me a new shirt as soon as possible. I loce my new shirt. Its SICK! Extremely nice shirt.
Would you order again? YES
New York, NY
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 20,
2013
Great fitting shirt at a great price!
Would you order again? YES
Baton Rouge, LA
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 20,
2013
Great experience on the site, great shirt too!
Would you order again? YES
Atlanta, GA
4/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
4/5
Fit
4/5
Service
May 19,
2013
First class products and customer service!!!!! It's hard to find both in one company these days.
Would you order again? YES
MARSHFELD, WI
5/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 18,
2013
Still working to get the exact fit, as I am really picky but they have been great in helping make any needed alterations.
Would you order again? YES
New York, NY
4/5
Website
3/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
3/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 18,
2013
My experience with proper cloth was amazing! After receiving my first custom shirt, which was very nearly perfect, I stopped by Proper Cloth in NY during a visit to ask for their help fine tuning the fit for my next order. They were great and knew just how to help. In fact, they even insisted that I leave my shirt there with them and they would make a new one complimentary based on the adjustments we made that day. I received my new shirt and it fits perfectly! I can honestly say this is the first shirt I have ever had that fits me just right. I love it and look forward to ordering more from them soon. I highly recommend them; they are professional and offer exceptional service.
Would you order again? YES
Washington, DC
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 17,
2013
Excellent in every way
Would you order again? YES
Miami, FL
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 17,
2013
Very good service and quick delivery. I would recommend Proper Cloth for friends that are tired of wearing shirts that don't fit.
Would you order again? YES
Washington, DC
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
May 16,
2013
Good experience. I was contacted immediately when it became clear that the rush option in my order couldn't be fulfilled. The refund was posted quickly. The fit of the shirt itself is great... better than I was expecting actually! I used a Smart Fit and I was impressed with how well it fit right out of the box!
Would you order again? YES
Ottawa, Ontario
5/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
Hold on! Loading more reviews...
Sign In
Sign In
Sign In