Explain Size
  
ABOUT
OUR STORY & SHIRTS
SCHEDULE A FITTING
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
FIT GUARANTEE
FAST DELIVERY
PRESS
CONTACT US
CUSTOM DRESS SHIRTS
DESIGN A SHIRT
SHIRT GALLERY
FABRICS
COLLAR STYLES
CUSTOM SIZES
GIFT CERTIFICATES
COLLECTIONS
ACCESSORIES
REFERENCE
LOG IN / SIGN UP
CUSTOMER REVIEWS (REALTIME, UNFILTERED, HONEST)
Based on  5,872   reviews:
96%  of customers say they will order from Proper Cloth again.
Yes
No
DATE PURCHASED COMMENTS RATINGS
April 22,
2014 11:42pm
Hundred bucks for a nice, perfect fitting shirt. No trip to the mall. No trip to the tailor.
Would you order again? YES
San Diego, CA
5/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 22,
2014 9:22pm
Questionnaire produced decent fit. Pleased that can alter first shirt for free. Will order more shirts over time.
Would you order again? YES
Ottawa, Ontario
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
4/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 22,
2014 9:12pm
Fitted at their place in SOHO, they nailed it. The whole experience is incredible, I don't want to buy a shirt anywhere else.
Would you order again? YES
Greenwich, CT
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 22,
2014 8:29pm
Extremely happy with all of the shirts I've ordered! Great fabric selection, great sizing options, great cuts!
Would you order again? YES
Knoxville, TN
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 22,
2014 7:13pm
I have now ordered several shirts from PC. In fact, it is the only place I am buying button down shirts. Why else would I or anyone else order a shirt that does not fit as well or that is not made as well? No reason.
Would you order again? YES
McAllen, TX
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 22,
2014 5:37pm
Excellent customer service, but I wish I had known the oxford cloths used shrink so much! Proper was very accommodating and remade the shirt at no cost to me.
Would you order again? YES
Richmond, VA
5/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 22,
2014 8:01am
Great experience. Very good, sturdy white shirt.
Would you order again? YES
Ellicott City, MD
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
4/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 10:20pm
Great fabric.
Would you order again? YES
Bedford, NH
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 10:19pm
Great fabric. Highly recommend.
Would you order again? YES
Bedford, NH
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 9:35pm
Excellent! Finally found a comfortable shirt that fits.
Would you order again? YES
Sicklerville, NJ
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 4:52pm
The default buttons are fairly easily dislodged from the buttonholes - especially when no placket has been chosen.
Would you order again? YES
Oakland, CA
4/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
3/5
Construction
3/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 2:43pm
Love all the design options!
Would you order again? YES
Edmonton, Alberta
5/5
Website
4/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
3/5
Service
April 21,
2014 1:51pm
Great site, spend the 20 min sizing yourself and then you're good to go. Best fitting shirt I've ever worn to date.
Would you order again? YES
Vernon, CT
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 11:21am
I have told everyone in my office of the amazing service that I received when I was in NY getting measured, as well as after receiving my first test shirt. Additionally, the fabrics are excellent quality and the shirts are well constructed. I will be making Proper Cloth my go to store for shirts.
Would you order again? YES
Vancouver, British Columbia
4/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 11:19am
All the fabrics I've had thus far have been very soft and don't wrinkle easily (and I'm on my 10th shirt since January). The sewing has been great as well. One thing I would recommend is to try out different collars. I started with the English Spread and realized it was too small for me when I got my first shirt (I'm 6'7) I switched to the President Spread and love it-I use this collar most of the time as it works both casual and with a tie. I highly recommend the President Point for shirts you will wear with a suit-PC's website describes it as best for lawyers, bankers, or corporate slaves over 6 feet tall. I think 6'2 would be more appropriate, as it's a stout collar, unless you're a stocky 6 feet. For sure, if you are over 6'4, the President Point is a must for any shirt you will wear with a suit in a traditional business situation.
Would you order again? YES
Roanoke, VA
4/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 9:53am
Follow the measurement directions = great shirt.
Would you order again? YES
Vass, NC
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 9:17am
Great service and exceptionally good communication.
Would you order again? YES
McLean, VA
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 21,
2014 7:12am
My experience was fantastic! A very efficient and nice customer service, a wide and luxurious range of fabrics available, a very good construction at very decent prices!
Would you order again? YES
NY, NY
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
4/5
Construction
4/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 20,
2014 7:48pm
The only place I order from.
Would you order again? YES
Phoenix, AZ
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 20,
2014 12:07pm
I went into the studio for a fitting, and I'd recommend doing so to anyone interested in using proper cloth. The details take were far more specific than I would have submitted over the web after self-measurement, and the result is one of the best fits that I've ever found in a shirt. The only adjustment that I'll make, in fact, is in the width of the cuff. Even that isn't big enough for me to consider having the shirt altered. It's a near enough thing that I'll merely adjust the size prior to my next order - and there most certainly will be a next order!
Would you order again? YES
San Francisco, CA
4/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 20,
2014 9:53am
My first shirt, and the fit is perfect! But, I haven't washed it yet, and you promise some shrinkage, so I'll have to wait awhile, but so far I'm perfectly satisfied.
Would you order again? YES
Ocala, FL
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 19,
2014 11:23pm
Great customer service!
Would you order again? YES
Brooklyn, NY
4/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 19,
2014 6:41pm
Best to get to the soho office to get measured - everyone there is really helpful, and you can see lots of fabric choices as well as get fitted.
Would you order again? YES
Oakhurst, NJ
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
4/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 19,
2014 5:42pm
Brittany in customer service is excellent! Thanks!
Would you order again? YES
East Norriton, PA
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
5/5
Service
April 19,
2014 11:41am
Shirts came in on time. Ordering and designing a shirt was simple and straightforward. I will be ordering with them again.
Would you order again? YES
Austin, TX
5/5
Website
5/5
Fabric
5/5
Construction
5/5
Fit
4/5
Service
Hold on! Loading more reviews...
Sign In
Sign In
Sign In